Skip to content

Best Payroll Services in Greencastle, IN (2026)

61 payroll services ranked by BKR ScoreUpdated 0 paid placements in this rankingHow we rank →

The short answer

  1. 1

    Best overall in Greencastle: AccuPay, BKR Score 58/100; 4.9★ from 163 Google reviews.

  2. 7

    Most-reviewed: TMA Accounting, 167 Google reviews at 5.0★, the most of 61 ranked; ranked #7.

Rankings can't be bought. Bookkeepers can't pay to change their rank or score. How we rank

61 Greencastle payroll services are ranked here by BKR Score, from nine published factors. 13 open Saturdays and 1 open Sundays, based on posted hours. The median Google rating is 4.8★ across 61 rated firms.

Top 10 payroll services in Greencastle at a glance

Services come from each firm’s own Google listing and name; we do not verify licenses, so confirm a CPA license at cpaverify.org (US) or with the provincial CPA body (Canada) before you rely on it.

Top 10 payroll services in Greencastle at a glance
RankBusinessBKR ScoreGoogle ratingBased inHoursBest for
1AccuPay584.9★ (163)Greenwood, 42 mi away—Overall
2ASAP Payroll Service554.8★ (66)Indianapolis, 38 mi away——
3Candoor Payroll & HCM544.9★ (51)Lafayette, 50 mi away——
4United Life Services Inc525.0★ (129)Indianapolis, 30 mi awaySat—
5Certified Payroll Associates, Inc.515.0★ (49)Brownsburg, 29 mi away——
6Aspire Tax505.0★ (94)Indianapolis, 39 mi awaySat—
7TMA Accounting505.0★ (167)Indianapolis, 44 mi away—Most reviews
8Sandhu CPA494.7★ (107)Greenwood, 42 mi awaySat—
9Paycom Indianapolis495.0★ (5)Indianapolis, 39 mi away——
10J.R. Helms & Associates, P.C.484.8★ (102)Indianapolis, 37 mi away——

The 61 best payroll services in Greencastle, ranked

Ordered by BKR Score, a 0–100 score from nine published factors. Paid placement never changes the order.

Services come from each firm’s own Google listing and name; we do not verify licenses, so confirm a CPA license at cpaverify.org (US) or with the provincial CPA body (Canada) before you rely on it.

Scores below: based on 8 of 9 factors; recency not yet collected. Hatched segments mark factors we don't have yet.

  1. Ranked #1 in Greencastle

    Based in Greenwood, 42 mi away

    58/100BKR Score

    Ranked #1 because of its Google rating and service focus: 4.9★ from 163 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Payroll service”.

    • 4.9★ from 163 Google reviews
    Hours
    Mon–Fri 8 AM–4:30 PM · Sat–Sun closed
    Address
    584 N Emerson Ave, Greenwood, IN 46143
  2. Based in Indianapolis, 38 mi away

    55/100BKR Score

    Ranked #2 because of its Google rating and service focus: 4.8★ from 66 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Payroll service”.

    • 4.8★ from 66 Google reviews
    Hours
    Mon–Thu 8 AM–4:30 PM · Fri 8 AM–3 PM · Sat–Sun closed
    Address
    8130 S Meridian St Suite 4C, Indianapolis, IN 46217
  3. Based in Lafayette, 50 mi away

    54/100BKR Score

    Ranked #3 because of its Google rating and service focus: 4.9★ from 51 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Payroll service”.

    • 4.9★ from 51 Google reviews
    Hours
    Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM · Sat–Sun closed
    Address
    2504 Veterans Memorial Pkwy S #1, Lafayette, IN 47909
  4. Based in Indianapolis, 39 mi away

    50/100BKR Score

    Ranked #6 because of its Google rating and review volume: 5.0★ from 94 Google reviews.

    • 5.0★ from 94 Google reviews
    Hours
    Mon–Fri 10 AM–6 PM · Sat 10 AM–5 PM · Sun closed
    Address
    8545 U.S. 31 N, Indianapolis, IN 46227
  5. Based in Indianapolis, 44 mi away

    50/100BKR Score

    Ranked #7 because of its Google rating and review volume: 5.0★ from 167 Google reviews, the most in Greencastle.

    • 5.0★ from 167 Google reviews
    Hours
    Mon–Fri 8 AM–4 PM · Sat–Sun closed
    Address
    9595 Whitley Dr #102, Indianapolis, IN 46240
  6. Based in Greenwood, 42 mi away

    49/100BKR Score

    Ranked #8 because of its Google rating and review volume: 4.7★ from 107 Google reviews.

    • 4.7★ from 107 Google reviews
    Hours
    Mon–Fri 9 AM–5 PM · Sat 10 AM–4 PM · Sun closed
    Address
    494 S Emerson Ave Suite E, Greenwood, IN 46143
  7. Based in Indianapolis, 39 mi away

    49/100BKR Score

    Ranked #9 because of its Google rating and service focus: 5.0★ from 5 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Payroll service”.

    • 5.0★ from 5 Google reviews
    Hours
    Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM · Sat–Sun closed
    Address
    10 W Market St #1030, Indianapolis, IN 46204
  8. Based in Indianapolis, 44 mi away

    48/100BKR Score

    Ranked #11 because of its Google rating and review volume: 4.7★ from 110 Google reviews.

    • 4.7★ from 110 Google reviews
    Hours
    Mon–Wed 10 AM–2 PM · Thu 2 PM–7 PM · Fri–Sat 10 AM–2 PM · Sun closed
    Address
    8487 Union Chapel Rd Ste 780, Indianapolis, IN 46240
  9. Based in Greenwood, 38 mi away

    48/100BKR Score

    Ranked #13 because of its Google rating and review volume: 4.7★ from 121 Google reviews.

    • 4.7★ from 121 Google reviews
    Hours
    Mon closed · Tue 10 AM–2 PM · Wed closed · Thu 1 PM–5 PM · Fri–Sun closed
    Address
    3100 Meridian Parke Dr Ste I, Greenwood, IN 46142
  10. Based in Plainfield, 26 mi away

    47/100BKR Score

    Ranked #15 because of its Google rating and review volume: 5.0★ from 41 Google reviews.

    • 5.0★ from 41 Google reviews
    Hours
    Mon closed · Tue 9 AM–3 PM · Wed closed · Thu 9 AM–3 PM · Fri–Sun closed
    Address
    1647 E Main St B, Plainfield, IN 46168
  11. Based in Greencastle

    47/100BKR Score

    Ranked #16 because of its Google rating and service focus: 4.4★ from 14 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Tax preparation service”.

    • 4.4★ from 14 Google reviews
    Hours
    Mon–Tue 9 AM–5 PM · Wed 9 AM–12 PM · Thu 9 AM–5 PM · Fri 9 AM–4 PM · Sat–Sun closed
    Address
    110 W Walnut St, Greencastle, IN 46135
  12. 46/100BKR Score

    Ranked #17 because of its Google rating and service focus: 5.0★ from 11 Google reviews, listed on Google as “Accounting firm”.

    • 5.0★ from 11 Google reviews
    Hours
    Mon–Fri 9 AM–5 PM · Sat–Sun closed
    Address
    7670 US-31, Indianapolis, IN 46227

Payroll services ranked #26 to #50

#1 to #25 are shown in full above. Here are #26 to #50, in BKR Score order; each links to its profile. We publish the top 50 of 61 ranked payroll services here; the rest are on their profiles.

payroll services in Greencastle, ranks 26 to 50
RankBusinessBKR ScoreGoogle ratingDistance
26Axiom Human Resource Solutions444.7★ (25)45 mi
27Larrison's Tax Service444.2★ (10)30 mi
28A.G. Financial & Associates, Inc444.9★ (16)33 mi
29Kristel's Tax & Accounting444.3★ (26)39 mi
30Marietta CPAs444.4★ (25)39 mi
31Tilson HR434.2★ (30)42 mi
32McCullough & Company Inc435.0★ (5)30 mi
33My Nguyen Financial Professional435.0★ (5)45 mi
34Palmer Accounting Services Inc.434.7★ (15)38 mi
35Plainfield Accounting Service LLC434.2★ (5)26 mi
36Circle City Taxes, LLC434.9★ (8)42 mi
37Edgewater CPA Group434.4★ (27)45 mi
38W/E CPA, LLC435.0★ (21)49 mi
39Milestone Accounting & HR435.0★ (13)43 mi
40Underwood Tax & Bookkeeping Service424.4★ (7)39 mi
41ATAX - Mooresville, IN425.0★ (8)26 mi
42Block Advisors423.8★ (29)39 mi
43B F Tax Management & Resolution Inc424.1★ (20)45 mi
44Lawrie & Dunbar, CPAs423.6★ (31)42 mi
45Kristina A. Freeman, EA425.0★ (6)31 mi
46Edgewater CPA Group425.0★ (5)42 mi
47Reliable Number Management425.0★ (4)26 mi
48Jayd Advisors - Shelley R Johnson CPA425.0★ (5)43 mi
49Poynter Financial Solutions415.0★ (4)28 mi
50ATAX – Rockville Rd, IN413.3★ (11)29 mi

Also serving Greencastle

20 more payroll services within 50 mi that we can't rank yet: too few reviews, or a service we couldn't confirm. Listed A to Z.

Unranked payroll services serving Greencastle
BusinessGoogle ratingDistance
Auris Payroll - Taylor Ryan5.0★ (1)38 mi
DM Bookkeeping Services5.0★ (1)37 mi
Earl & Co5.0★ (2)In Greencastle
EZ Tax Advisors5.0★ (2)47 mi
H&L BookkeepingIn Greencastle
H&R Block4.6★ (79)In Greencastle
Hammer & Swigart, CPAs, Inc.3.7★ (3)In Greencastle
Joy Bookkeeping5.0★ (2)9 mi
Miami Account & Tax Services4.0★ (1)40 mi
On-Site BookkeepingIn Greencastle
Payroll Authority, LLC24 mi
Pershing & Co5.0★ (4)In Greencastle
Profit & Growth Experts5.0★ (1)40 mi
RDS Tax Consultants, LLC1.0★ (1)45 mi
Stafford & Cummings Bookkeeping & Tax5.0★ (2)In Greencastle
Theatrical Payroll Services4.0★ (1)37 mi
TTZLLC26 mi
United Accounting Solutions5.0★ (1)24 mi
Webb ShackleIn Greencastle
Webb Shackle5.0★ (1)29 mi

How we ranked Greencastle payroll services

We scored 61 Greencastle payroll services on nine factors, weighted as shown. A firm is ranked when its service is confirmed and it has 3 or more Google reviews or a claimed profile. A firm with no Google reviews scores zero on rating, review volume and recency. Other unknown factors are left out, not counted as zero. Scores last refreshed November 9, 2026.

Paid placement never changes a rank or score. Sponsored businesses are paid, labelled, limited to 3 and shown above the ranking, outside it.

Read the full method: formula, sources and exclusions

BKR Score factors and weights
FactorWeightComputed fromIn Greencastle data
Reputation25%Google star rating, adjusted for how many reviews back itMeasured
Review volume12%Number of Google reviews, compared with the most-reviewed firm on the listMeasured
Recency8%Share of reviews from the last 12 monthsNot yet collected
Availability5%Weekly open hours, Saturday, Sunday, and same-day appointmentsMeasured
Service focus15%How clearly the firm offers this service (its Google category and name)Measured
Proximity5%Based in the city scores highest, less the farther away it isMeasured
Claimed profile10%The firm has claimed its Bookkeepers Ranked profile (free or paid earn the same)Measured
Partnered5%The firm links to Bookkeepers Ranked from its own website with our badge, checked periodicallyMeasured
Bookkeepers Ranked reviews15%Verified client reviews collected by Bookkeepers Ranked: their rating and how many there areMeasured

How to choose a payroll service

  1. List your employee count, pay frequency and every state or province where employees work.
  2. Ask whether the service deposits payroll taxes and files quarterly and year-end forms for you.
  3. Ask whether it covers penalties caused by its own errors.
  4. Ask what costs extra: year-end forms, new-hire reporting, benefits deductions, off-cycle runs.
  5. Ask how you can see tax deposits and filings made in your name.
  6. Check recent reviews from employers of your size.

Questions to ask a payroll service

  • Do you deposit payroll taxes and file all quarterly and year-end forms for me?
  • Which states, provinces and localities do you handle?
  • Do you cover penalties caused by your own errors?
  • What does each pay run cost, and what are the extras?
  • How do I see deposits and filings made in my name?
  • What happens to my payroll records if I leave?

Terms explained

Bookkeeping
Recording a business’s transactions and keeping its accounts reconciled and current.
Reconciliation
Matching the books to bank, card and loan statements so every balance agrees.
Catch-up bookkeeping
Bringing books that are months or years behind up to date; usually quoted separately from monthly work.
Chart of accounts
The list of accounts (income, expenses, assets, liabilities, equity) a business records transactions in.
Cash vs. accrual basis
Cash basis records income and expenses when money moves; accrual basis records them when they are earned or incurred.
Month-end close
The routine of reconciling, adjusting and reviewing the books so a month’s reports are final.
CPA (US)
Certified public accountant: a license issued by a state board of accountancy after the Uniform CPA Examination, education and experience requirements.
CPA (Canada)
Chartered Professional Accountant: a designation reserved for members of a provincial CPA body.
Enrolled agent (EA)
A tax practitioner licensed by the IRS who may represent any taxpayer before the IRS.
PTIN
Preparer Tax Identification Number: required of anyone paid to prepare US federal tax returns.
Annual Filing Season Program (AFSP)
A voluntary IRS continuing-education program for preparers who are not CPAs, enrolled agents or attorneys; it gives limited representation rights.
Attest services
Audits, reviews and other reports that give assurance on financial statements; in the US only licensed CPA firms may issue them.

Payroll services in Greencastle: frequently asked questions

Who is the best payroll service in Greencastle?

By BKR Score, the highest-ranked payroll service in Greencastle, IN is AccuPay with a BKR Score of 58/100. It has 4.9★ from 163 Google reviews. ASAP Payroll Service (#2) and Candoor Payroll & HCM (#3) follow. We ranked 61 payroll services on nine factors, last updated November 9, 2026.

How many payroll services are there in Greencastle?

BookkeepersRanked ranks 61 payroll services serving Greencastle, IN. 1 of them is based in Greencastle; the rest serve it from nearby towns. Another 20 within 50 mi are listed but not ranked yet. Counts are as of November 2026.

Which payroll services in Greencastle work on weekends?

13 of 61 ranked payroll services post Saturday hours and 1 post Sunday hours. The highest-ranked open Saturdays are United Life Services Inc (#4), Aspire Tax (#6) and Sandhu CPA (#8). Many firms add evening and weekend hours only in tax season.

What Google rating do Greencastle payroll services have?

The median Google rating among 61 rated payroll services in Greencastle is 4.8★, with a median of 15 reviews. TMA Accounting has the most, 167 reviews, and ranks #7. We adjust ratings for review count, so a few five-star reviews cannot top the list.

How does BookkeepersRanked rank payroll services?

Each payroll service gets a 0–100 BKR Score from nine published factors, led by reputation (25%), service focus (15%), bookkeepers ranked reviews (15%) and review volume (12%). A firm with no Google reviews scores zero on rating, review volume and recency; other factors we cannot measure are left out. Only firms with a confirmed service and 3 or more reviews, or a claimed profile, are ranked.

Do payroll services outside Greencastle count in this ranking?

Yes, if they are within 50 mi of the Greencastle city center, our service radius for payroll services. Each listing shows where the firm is based and how far away it is. Proximity is 5% of the BKR Score, so a nearby firm gets a small edge.

Can payroll services pay to rank higher on BookkeepersRanked?

No. The BKR Score never reads payment status, and this ranking has 0 paid placements. Up to 3 Featured firms may appear above the list, labelled Sponsored and showing their honest rank.

Am I still responsible for payroll taxes if I use a payroll service?

Yes. The IRS holds the employer responsible for depositing and reporting employment taxes, even when a third-party payroll service does the work. Ask how the service deposits taxes and whether it will cover penalties caused by its own errors.

What does a payroll service usually include?

Calculating pay and withholdings, paying employees, depositing payroll taxes, filing quarterly and year-end forms, and issuing year-end slips to employees. Benefits deductions, multi-state payroll and time tracking are often extras.

Does a payroll service need to be based in Greencastle?

No. Payroll is run online, so many services work with employers anywhere. Make sure the service handles the state, provincial and local taxes where your employees work.

Update log for Greencastle

  1. November 2026: BKR Scores recalculated for 61 payroll services serving Greencastle.