Skip to content

Payroll Services in Indiana: Ranked Lists by City (2026)

83 cities with a ranked listUpdated 0 paid placements in any rankingHow we rank →

We rank payroll services in 83 Indiana cities, 6,305 city rankings in all. The largest lists are East Chicago (224), Munster (223) and Hammond (222).

Payroll services by city in Indiana

Every Indiana city with a ranked list of payroll services, largest first. Each list ranks firms within 50 mi of the city.

Services come from each firm’s own Google listing and name; we do not verify licenses, so confirm a CPA license at cpaverify.org (US) or with the provincial CPA body (Canada) before you rely on it.

Payroll services ranked by city in Indiana
CityRankedRanked #1Its BKR Score
Payroll services in East Chicago224Connor & Gallagher OneSource (CGO)55
Payroll services in Munster223Connor & Gallagher OneSource (CGO)55
Payroll services in Hammond222Connor & Gallagher OneSource (CGO)55
Payroll services in Dyer218Connor & Gallagher OneSource (CGO)55
Payroll services in Highland218Connor & Gallagher OneSource (CGO)55
Payroll services in Gary211Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana55
Payroll services in Griffith209Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana54
Payroll services in Schererville203Connor & Gallagher OneSource (CGO)54
Payroll services in Saint John200Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana56
Payroll services in Merrillville192Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana55
Payroll services in Lake Station186Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana55
Payroll services in Cedar Lake182Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana54
Payroll services in Crown Point182Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana55
Payroll services in Hobart182Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana55
Payroll services in Portage174Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana55
Payroll services in Chesterton148Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana54
Payroll services in Valparaiso115Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana55
Payroll services in Michigan City114Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana53
Payroll services in Westfield74AccuPay58
Payroll services in Fairfield Heights73AccuPay59
Payroll services in Zionsville73AccuPay58
Payroll services in Brownsburg71AccuPay59
Payroll services in Carmel71AccuPay58
Payroll services in Greenfield71AccuPay59
Payroll services in Lawrence71AccuPay59
Payroll services in Anderson69AccuPay57
Payroll services in Avon69AccuPay59
Payroll services in Broad Ripple69AccuPay59
Payroll services in Beech Grove68AccuPay60
Payroll services in Franklin68AccuPay60
Payroll services in Indianapolis68AccuPay60
Payroll services in Lebanon68AccuPay57
Payroll services in Noblesville68AccuPay58
Payroll services in Speedway68AccuPay59
Payroll services in Greenwood67AccuPay61
Payroll services in Richmond67PayOptions54
Payroll services in Shelbyville67AccuPay59
Payroll services in Fishers66AccuPay59
Payroll services in Plainfield65AccuPay59
Payroll services in Martinsville64AccuPay59
Payroll services in Frankfort63Candoor Payroll & HCM57
Payroll services in New Castle63AccuPay56
Payroll services in Yorktown63AccuPay56
Payroll services in Greencastle61AccuPay58
Payroll services in Crawfordsville60Candoor Payroll & HCM57
Payroll services in Connersville57PayOptions55
Payroll services in Kokomo50Candoor Payroll & HCM55
Payroll services in Muncie49Performance Financial - Tax, Accounting, Payroll and Insurance53
Payroll services in Greensburg44AccuPay57
Payroll services in Columbus42AccuPay58
Payroll services in LaPorte41Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana55
Payroll services in Marion41Performance Financial - Tax, Accounting, Payroll and Insurance52
Payroll services in Madison40Payroll Vault Indianapolis, Indiana54
Payroll services in La Porte39Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana54
Payroll services in North Madison38Payroll Vault Indianapolis, Indiana54
Payroll services in Bloomington37AccuPay58
Payroll services in Clarksville35Adele's Tax Service and Consulting55
Payroll services in Goshen35GT Independence58
Payroll services in Jeffersonville35Adele's Tax Service and Consulting55
Payroll services in New Albany35Adele's Tax Service and Consulting55
Payroll services in Warsaw31GT Independence55
Payroll services in South Bend29GT Independence56
Payroll services in Mishawaka28GT Independence56
Payroll services in Elkhart27GT Independence57
Payroll services in Granger27GT Independence56
Payroll services in Seymour27AccuPay57
Payroll services in Plymouth26Payroll Vault Crown Point, Indiana52
Payroll services in Auburn24GT Independence56
Payroll services in Fort Wayne24GT Independence55
Payroll services in Huntington24Miller CPA Group, LLC52
Payroll services in Wabash24Miller CPA Group, LLC50
Payroll services in Bluffton23Miller CPA Group, LLC51
Payroll services in Lafayette22Candoor Payroll & HCM60
Payroll services in Peru20Candoor Payroll & HCM54
Payroll services in New Haven19Miller CPA Group, LLC53
Payroll services in West Lafayette14Candoor Payroll & HCM62
Payroll services in Jasper13Kemper 1st Choice Payroll - Payroll Services55
Payroll services in Evansville12Kemper 1st Choice Payroll - Payroll Services59
Payroll services in Logansport12Candoor Payroll & HCM58
Payroll services in Terre Haute10Moran Tax & Accounting LLC51
Payroll services in Vincennes9Kemper 1st Choice Payroll - Payroll Services54
Payroll services in Bedford8Payroll Vault Indianapolis, Indiana57
Payroll services in Washington6Kemper 1st Choice Payroll - Payroll Services54

Highest BKR Scores among Indiana payroll services

Each score is computed within its own city list, so use the city pages to compare businesses. Shown for orientation, not as a state ranking.

Services come from each firm’s own Google listing and name; we do not verify licenses, so confirm a CPA license at cpaverify.org (US) or with the provincial CPA body (Canada) before you rely on it.