Skip to content

Payroll Services in New York: Ranked Lists by City (2026)

311 cities with a ranked listUpdated 0 paid placements in any rankingHow we rank →

We rank payroll services in 311 New York cities, 129,153 city rankings in all. The largest lists are Elmhurst (584), Jackson Heights (584) and East Tremont (583).

Payroll services by city in New York

Every New York city with a ranked list of payroll services, largest first. Each list ranks firms within 50 mi of the city.

Services come from each firm’s own Google listing and name; we do not verify licenses, so confirm a CPA license at cpaverify.org (US) or with the provincial CPA body (Canada) before you rely on it.

Payroll services ranked by city in New York
CityRankedRanked #1Its BKR Score
Payroll services in Elmhurst584Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Jackson Heights584Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in East Tremont583Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Forest Hills583Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Kew Gardens583Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Parkchester583Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Rego Park583Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Unionport583Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Whitestone583Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Woodside583Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Astoria582Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in East Harlem582Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Harlem582Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Long Island City582Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Richmond Hill582Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Throgs Neck582Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Briarwood581Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Corona581Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Fordham581Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Hunts Point581Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Kew Gardens Hills581Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Maspeth581Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Middle Village581Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Morris Heights581Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Mott Haven581Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in The Bronx581Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Washington Heights581Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Woodhaven581Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Baychester580Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Glendale580Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Melrose580Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Morrisania580Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Sunnyside580Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Tremont580Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Van Nest580Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Bayside579Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Bushwick579Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in College Point579Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in East Elmhurst579Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Manhattan579Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Morris Park579Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Ridgewood579Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Spuyten Duyvil579Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Williamsburg579Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Brownsville578Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Cypress Hills578Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in East New York578Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Greenpoint578Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Inwood578Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Jamaica578Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Kings Bridge578Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Morningside Heights578Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Queens578Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in University Heights578Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Bergen Beach577Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Brooklyn577Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Flatbush577Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Ozone Park577Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Borough Park576Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Douglaston576Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in East Flatbush576Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in East Village576Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Flatlands576Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Gramercy Park576Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Hillside576Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Howard Beach576Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Park Slope576Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Port Richmond576Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Sunset Park576Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Bensonhurst575Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Brooklyn Heights575Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Eastchester575Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Fort Hamilton575Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Fresh Meadows575Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Hell's Kitchen575Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Kensington575Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Little Neck575Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in New York City575Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Queens Village575Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Springfield Gardens575Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Arrochar574Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Bath Beach574Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Chinatown574Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Dyker Heights574Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Emerson Hill574Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Far Rockaway574Zuma Payroll & Processing57
Payroll services in Graniteville574Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Mariners Harbor574Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Sheepshead Bay574Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Wakefield574Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Brighton Beach573Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Canarsie573Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Coney Island573Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Financial District573Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Gravesend573Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Hollis573Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Terrace Heights573Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Wykagyl573Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Arverne572Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Cambria Heights572Zuma Payroll & Processing57
Payroll services in Elmont572Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Great Neck572Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Laurelton572Zuma Payroll & Processing57
Payroll services in Mount Vernon572Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in New Rochelle572Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Oakwood572Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Rosedale572Zuma Payroll & Processing57
Payroll services in Seaside572Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Floral Park571Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in North New Hyde Park571Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in North Valley Stream571Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Woodmere571Zuma Payroll & Processing57
Payroll services in Yonkers571Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Valley Stream570Zuma Payroll & Processing57
Payroll services in Franklin Square569Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Great Kills569Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Lynbrook569Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Staten Island569Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Mamaroneck568Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in New Springville568Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Port Washington568Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Rockville Centre568Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Rossville568Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Mineola567Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Eltingville566Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Garden City566Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Long Beach566Zuma Payroll & Processing57
Payroll services in West Hempstead566Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Woodrow566Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Dobbs Ferry565Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Hempstead565Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Oceanside565Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Baldwin563Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Greenburgh562Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Glen Cove561Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in North Merrick561Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Roosevelt561Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Uniondale561Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Freeport560Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Merrick559Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Westbury559Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Scarsdale558Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in East Meadow555Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Harrison555Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Tarrytown554Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in White Plains554Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Port Chester553Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Salisbury553Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Bellmore552Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in New Cassel552Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Rye552Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in North Bellmore550Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Sleepy Hollow550Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Pearl River547Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in Nanuet545Nationwide Merchant Solutions59
Payroll services in North Wantagh543Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in North Castle542Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Wantagh542Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Jericho540Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Hicksville537Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Levittown537Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Ossining536Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Mount Kisco535Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Seaford533Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Spring Valley532Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Bethpage530Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Monsey530Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Syosset530Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Massapequa529Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in New City528Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Plainview528Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Suffern526Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in North Massapequa523Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Massapequa Park522Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in South Farmingdale520Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in East Massapequa517Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Haverstraw517Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Huntington517Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Melville515Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in North Amityville515Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in West Haverstraw515Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Huntington Station514Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Stony Point509Nationwide Merchant Solutions58
Payroll services in Greenlawn507Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Copiague506Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in North Lindenhurst505Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Peekskill504Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in East Northport503Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Wyandanch501Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Dix Hills500Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Elwood500Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Lindenhurst499Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Deer Park497Reliable Payroll Services59
Payroll services in West Babylon497Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Commack494Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Babylon493Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Fort Salonga493Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Jefferson Valley-Yorktown493Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in North Babylon493Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in West Islip489Reliable Payroll Services59
Payroll services in Kings Park486Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in North Bay Shore477Reliable Payroll Services59
Payroll services in Brentwood475Reliable Payroll Services59
Payroll services in Bay Shore467Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Hauppauge456Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Smithtown456Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Central Islip451Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Islip449Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Saint James443Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Stony Brook435Zuma Payroll & Processing57
Payroll services in Nesconset434Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in East Islip430Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Lake Ronkonkoma426Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Lake Grove422Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Centereach417Reliable Payroll Services57
Payroll services in Ronkonkoma413Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Bohemia412Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Kiryas Joel410Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Woodbury403Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in East Setauket399Zuma Payroll & Processing57
Payroll services in Sayville396Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Setauket-East Setauket396Zuma Payroll & Processing57
Payroll services in Holbrook391Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Terryville361Reliable Payroll Services57
Payroll services in Holtsville358Reliable Payroll Services57
Payroll services in Selden320Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Farmingville319Reliable Payroll Services59
Payroll services in Mount Sinai297Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Patchogue297Reliable Payroll Services59
Payroll services in Coram292Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Medford285Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in East Patchogue278Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Miller Place271Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Middle Island227Reliable Payroll Services60
Payroll services in North Bellport226Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Rocky Point203Zuma Payroll & Processing60
Payroll services in Niagara Falls202HeartPayroll57
Payroll services in Ridge186Zuma Payroll & Processing60
Payroll services in Newburgh183Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Beacon181Nationwide Merchant Solutions56
Payroll services in Middletown163Nationwide Merchant Solutions57
Payroll services in Shirley150Reliable Payroll Services60
Payroll services in Manorville139Zuma Payroll & Processing59
Payroll services in Mastic Beach139Reliable Payroll Services60
Payroll services in Mastic132Reliable Payroll Services60
Payroll services in Riverhead111Zuma Payroll & Processing58
Payroll services in Grand Island109HeartPayroll58
Payroll services in Hampton Bays84Reliable Payroll Services58
Payroll services in Lockport81HeartPayroll58
Payroll services in North Tonawanda69HeartPayroll58
Payroll services in Poughkeepsie58SwiftChecks Payroll Services55
Payroll services in Batavia57Optima Benefits & Payroll58
Payroll services in Geneva48Optima Benefits & Payroll57
Payroll services in Tonawanda46RPM Payroll56
Payroll services in Kenmore38RPM Payroll56
Payroll services in Dunkirk36RPM Payroll55
Payroll services in Fredonia35RPM Payroll55
Payroll services in Amherst34Next HR Solutions59
Payroll services in Buffalo34RPM Payroll59
Payroll services in Eggertsville34RPM Payroll59
Payroll services in Gates-North Gates34Optima Benefits & Payroll61
Payroll services in Greece34Optima Benefits & Payroll60
Payroll services in Auburn33ConnectPay Payroll Services57
Payroll services in Brighton33Optima Benefits & Payroll61
Payroll services in Canandaigua33Optima Benefits & Payroll59
Payroll services in Irondequoit33Optima Benefits & Payroll61
Payroll services in Rochester33Optima Benefits & Payroll61
Payroll services in Cheektowaga32RPM Payroll59
Payroll services in Depew32Next HR Solutions59
Payroll services in Lackawanna32RPM Payroll59
Payroll services in Lancaster32Next HR Solutions59
Payroll services in West Seneca32RPM Payroll59
Payroll services in Wawarsing31Reliable Accounting and Tax Preparation54
Payroll services in Syracuse28ConnectPay Payroll Services62
Payroll services in Fairmount27ConnectPay Payroll Services61
Payroll services in Cortland26Prime Payroll Relief60
Payroll services in Utica26ConnectPay Payroll Services55
Payroll services in Oneida25ConnectPay Payroll Services60
Payroll services in Ithaca24Payco59
Payroll services in Gloversville23GTM Payroll Services59
Payroll services in Rome23ConnectPay Payroll Services59
Payroll services in Albany22GTM Payroll Services61
Payroll services in Fallsburg22Reliable Accounting and Tax Preparation55
Payroll services in Roessleville22GTM Payroll Services62
Payroll services in West Albany22GTM Payroll Services62
Payroll services in Cohoes21GTM Payroll Services62
Payroll services in Glens Falls21GTM Payroll Services59
Payroll services in Latham21GTM Payroll Services62
Payroll services in Oswego21ConnectPay Payroll Services57
Payroll services in Rotterdam21GTM Payroll Services63
Payroll services in Schenectady21GTM Payroll Services62
Payroll services in Troy21GTM Payroll Services62
Payroll services in Watervliet21GTM Payroll Services62
Payroll services in Fulton20ConnectPay Payroll Services59
Payroll services in Ogdensburg20Numetrica Accounting & Bookkeeping50
Payroll services in Queensbury20GTM Payroll Services59
Payroll services in Saratoga Springs20GTM Payroll Services61
Payroll services in Amsterdam19GTM Payroll Services60
Payroll services in Kingston19Reliable Accounting and Tax Preparation53
Payroll services in Massena17Numetrica Accounting & Bookkeeping50
Payroll services in Binghamton14Payco62
Payroll services in Johnson City13Payco63
Payroll services in Endicott12Payco62
Payroll services in Endwell12Payco62
Payroll services in Jamestown10Janine Anderson's Accounting Solutions59
Payroll services in Fort Drum8Amo Income Tax Services56
Payroll services in Oneonta8Key Accounting Solutions, LLC49
Payroll services in Watertown8Amo Income Tax Services56
Payroll services in Plattsburgh7Liberty Tax51
Payroll services in Elmira6Payco58
Payroll services in Corning5PAYLINX, LLC.56

Highest BKR Scores among New York payroll services

Each score is computed within its own city list, so use the city pages to compare businesses. Shown for orientation, not as a state ranking.

Services come from each firm’s own Google listing and name; we do not verify licenses, so confirm a CPA license at cpaverify.org (US) or with the provincial CPA body (Canada) before you rely on it.

Highest BKR Scores among New York payroll services
#FirmBKR ScoreCity listGoogle rating
1GTM Payroll Services63#1 in Rotterdam4.9★ (668)
2Payco63#1 in Johnson City5.0★ (87)
3ConnectPay Payroll Services62#1 in Syracuse4.9★ (76)
4Optima Benefits & Payroll61#1 in Rochester4.8★ (148)
5Prime Payroll Relief60#1 in Cortland5.0★ (41)
6Reliable Payroll Services60#1 in Shirley5.0★ (335)
7Zuma Payroll & Processing60#1 in Rocky Point5.0★ (436)
8Alliance Payroll Solutions60#2 in Brighton4.9★ (79)
9RPM Payroll59#1 in Buffalo5.0★ (35)
10Nationwide Merchant Solutions59#1 in Yonkers4.8★ (59)