Skip to content

Totaro & CoTax preparer in Toms River, NJ

Totaro & Co is a tax preparer at 10 Allen St STE 2B, Toms River, NJ 08753, ranked #33 of 149 tax preparers in Toms River and rated 4.7 from 14 Google reviews. Open Monday to Saturday.

Facts on this page come from public sources and the firm itself. Confirm credentials, the services included and fees in writing before you engage a firm.

Toms River, NJUpdated 0 paid placements in any rankingHow we rank

Key facts

Key facts about Totaro & Co
Address10 Allen St STE 2B, Toms River, NJ 08753Get directions
Phone(732) 341-1773
Websitetotaroandco.com
HoursMonday to Friday: 9 AM – 5 PM; Saturday: 9 AM – 1 PM
Google rating4.7 from 14 Google reviews

Services

Each service shows the evidence we matched it on.

  • Tax Preparationmain serviceGoogle main category
  • Bookkeepingadditional Google category
  • Accountingadditional Google category

Service area

Serves Toms River and 11 towns within 25 miles: Beachwood, Bayville, Holiday City-Berkeley, Lakewood, Point Pleasant, Ocean Acres, Browns Mills, West Freehold, Asbury Park, Freehold and Tinton Falls.

Based in Toms River, NJView on map

Opening hours

Opening hours for Totaro & Co
DayHours
Monday9 AM – 5 PM
Tuesday9 AM – 5 PM
Wednesday9 AM – 5 PM
Thursday9 AM – 5 PM
Friday9 AM – 5 PM
Saturday9 AM – 1 PM
SundayClosed
  • Open evenings — no
  • Open Saturdays
  • Open Sundays — no

Questions about Totaro & Co

How is Totaro & Co ranked in Toms River?

Totaro & Co is ranked #33 of 149 tax preparers in Toms River by BKR Score, with 56 out of 100 as of November 2026. The score weighs reputation, review volume, recency, availability, service focus, proximity, claimed profile, partnered and bookkeepers ranked reviews. No business can pay to change its rank.

What are Totaro & Co’s hours?

Totaro & Co is open Monday to Saturday. Its listed hours are Monday to Friday, 9 AM – 5 PM; Saturday, 9 AM – 1 PM. On Saturdays it is open 9 AM to 1 PM and closed on Sundays. Hours come from the business listing; holiday hours may differ.

What areas does Totaro & Co serve?

Serves Toms River and 11 towns within 25 miles: Beachwood, Bayville, Holiday City-Berkeley, Lakewood, Point Pleasant, Ocean Acres, Browns Mills, West Freehold, Asbury Park, Freehold and Tinton Falls. The list is based on the business's location and the usual service radius for tax preparation. Confirm your address is covered when you call.

What do Google reviews say about Totaro & Co?

Totaro & Co has a rating of 4.7 from 14 Google reviews. The BKR Score adjusts the star rating for review count, so a high rating from a few reviews counts for less than the same rating from many.

How do I contact Totaro & Co?

Call Totaro & Co on (732) 341-1773. The business is at 10 Allen St STE 2B, Toms River, NJ 08753. Its website is linked in the key facts on this page. Ask for the fee and what it includes in writing before work starts.

Own Totaro & Co? Claim this profile.

Claiming is free. Correct your hours, services and service area. The BKR Score is recalculated from corrected data; payment never changes it.

Claim this profile

Compare nearby tax preparers

Totaro & Co compared with nearby businesses
BusinessRankBKR ScoreGoogle ratingSaturdaySundayDistance away
Totaro & Co (this business)—564.7 (14)YesNo
Tax Pros Inc#31574.5 (34)YesNo6.8 mi
Classic Tax & Accounting Services#32575.0 (10)——1.3 mi
Block Advisors#34564.8 (57)NoNo7.2 mi

See all 149 ranked tax preparers in Toms River